Doesn't take much to total one of these out, considering parts, labor, paint, etc. Frankly, I think Progressive will be looking to write that one off. You might be able to buy it back from them as a salvage bike and try and patch it back together, but any resale value will be pretty non-existent.
My bike has already gathered a collection of dings and scratches. I have comprehensive on it too, but it's just not worth forking over the deductible to fix every minor little thing. The one positive about it is, I don't worry so much about getting that first scratch, so there is that. Sorry this happened to you, some people are just like that, unfortunately. Hope you can get it resolved to your satisfaction.